Stewart’s Shops Corp. recalled Heavenly Medley and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry ice cream in half-gallon paper cartons after a shopper found a metal object in one container, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration said in an Oct. 2 notice.
Products and dates
The Saratoga Springs, New York, convenience chain sold the affected flavors at all Stewart’s locations in New York, Vermont, and New Hampshire between July 17 and Oct. 2, 2026. Recalled Heavenly Medley carries a best-by date of Feb. 10, 2027, and UPC ending in 44371; Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry lists Feb. 11, 2027, and UPC ending in 44377.
No injuries or illnesses had been reported when the FDA published the alert. Stewart’s said it stopped production on the line involved and is investigating how metal entered the supply chain.
What consumers should do
Do not eat ice cream from the listed cartons. Return them to any Stewart’s Shop for a refund or throw them away in a sealed bag so other people or animals cannot access the product. Freezer photos of the UPC and best-by date help store staff verify eligibility if you lack a receipt.
If you already served the ice cream at a party, warn guests and monitor for mouth or throat injuries. Seek medical care if someone swallowed a sharp fragment or feels persistent pain.
Why metal recalls keep happening
Foreign-object recalls in dairy plants often trace to worn processing equipment, staples from packaging suppliers, or maintenance tools left near open vats. Regulators treat them seriously because metal shards can perforate tissue, even when batches look normal from the outside.
The recall is unrelated to listeria concerns that prompted a separate nationwide pull of Walmart’s bettergoods lemon Alfredo pasta earlier in the week. Ice cream recalls typically move faster through regional chains because distribution is concentrated and lot codes are narrow.
Broader food-safety context
October has been busy on the FDA recall calendar, with allergen mislabeling on frozen pizza and salmonella concerns on broccoli seeds also posted. For households stocking freezers ahead of the holidays, it is worth checking FDA.gov alerts once a week and matching UPCs when manufacturers expand lots.
Stewart’s Shops built its brand on house-made ice cream at highway convenience stores; a single consumer complaint triggered this pull. That is how the system is supposed to work, but it also means the first signal of trouble may be someone’s kitchen spoon—not a government inspector.
