Australia's Commonwealth Ombudsman has urged Parliament to let aged-care assessors override automated decisions from the federal government's Integrated Assessment Tool, saying the algorithm has produced unfair outcomes and no public explanation of how it ranks frail older Australians. The findings, released Monday, land as MPs return to Canberra for tributes to wounded Indi MP Helen Haines and as the Support at Home program faces a separate government-ordered review.
What the investigation found
The Department of Health, Disability and Ageing rolled the IAT into its Single Assessment System on 1 November 2025 for home-care packages that now touch about 1.1 million people. Ombudsman Iain Anderson said assessors and clinicians reported cases where the tool under-estimated needs yet could not be changed because the law treats the algorithm's output as final.
"Currently, under the law, automated decisions made by the IAT's algorithm cannot be overridden and changed, even if they are clinically inappropriate," Anderson said. He added that a reasonable person would lack confidence that the system is fair, citing complaints about long waits, poor communication and assessors with thin geriatric training.
The office also noted that no meaningful public documentation explains how the tool reaches a classification, a gap Anderson said conflicts with transparency recommendations from the Robodebt Royal Commission on government automation.
Ten recommendations on the table
Anderson issued 10 recommendations, including amending legislation to permit human overrides, reviewing the business rules behind the algorithm and consulting the public before further changes. He asked the Australian National Audit Office to consider a performance audit of how the department spent money building and running the system.
The department told SBS News it accepted relevant recommendations; Guardian Australia reported that officials are already commissioning an independent review of assessment mechanics, with findings due in the first half of 2027. Geriatricians' groups, including the Australian and New Zealand Society for Geriatric Medicine, warn that older Australians cannot wait that long for interim fixes when assessments gate access to showers, meals and nursing visits.
Political and clinical stakes
Labor's Support at Home reforms were meant to streamline entry to subsidised care, but Senate estimates hearings in August heard that the IAT may lean on only a fraction of the hundreds of questions collected during in-home visits. Opposition MPs are likely to use Anderson's report during this week's estimates to press ministers on whether cost containment trumped clinical judgment.
For families, the immediate issue is appeals: the ombudsman catalogued slow review pathways that left people without approved hours while automated scores stood. Advocates want a rapid clinical escalation line, not only the dispute processes the government has promised in parallel with the longer review.
What happens next
Minister for Aged Care Sam Rae must table a formal government response in Parliament. Lawyers for community legal centres say overriding automation will require primary legislation, not just rule tweaks, because the IAT's authority is embedded in the Aged Care Act framework. Until MPs act, assessors remain bound to scores they cannot fix, and the ombudsman's verdict gives older Australians a rare official admission that the country's flagship aged-care algorithm failed the fairness test ministers said it would meet.
