Federal prosecutors moved to charge former FBI Director James Comey for a third time this month, unsealing a case on Monday that accuses him of transmitting national-defense information and conspiring to do so in connection with a 2016 newspaper article. The filing had stayed under seal since October 5, when the Justice Department lodged a criminal information rather than seeking a grand jury indictment.
What the government alleges
The two counts rely on the Espionage Act. Court papers say Comey, while FBI director, directed staff to speak with New York Times reporter Charlie Savage about accuracy concerns in press coverage of U.S. email surveillance. The Times published a story on October 5, 2016, headlined “Yahoo Said to Have Aided U.S. Email Surveillance by Adapting Spam Filter,” citing unnamed government officials.
Prosecutors allege Comey sought to correct a Reuters article from the day before and that the contact with Savage amounted to an unauthorized transfer of sensitive material. Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Dustin Farahnak wrote that investigators found evidence Comey “directed staff to speak to Mr. Savage about specific accuracy concerns” linked to the earlier Reuters piece.
Why the case surfaced now
The Justice Department filed under seal to protect unnamed co-conspirators and ongoing inquiries, according to its October sealing motion. Comey’s lawyers asked U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden to unseal the matter, and the government did not object. McFadden ordered the case opened on October 26, making the charges public a day before Comey responded on video.
A department spokesperson said the criminal information was filed to preserve the statute of limitations before it expired this month. The alleged conduct dates to the same calendar day in 2016 — exactly ten years before the information was lodged — which Comey’s defense team argues should bar prosecution because the government did not obtain an indictment within the statutory window.
Comey’s response and prior cases
Comey called the prosecution an “appalling abuse” of the Justice Department in a Substack video after the unsealing. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald said Comey “steadfastly maintains his innocence” and noted prior Trump-era reviews concluded no charges were warranted.
The former director has been a focal point for President Donald Trump since the FBI opened its Russia interference investigation in 2016. Two earlier federal cases against Comey remain pending on separate allegations; this third matter does not yet include a grand jury indictment, meaning Comey cannot be tried on the information alone unless he waives that requirement.
What happens next
Comey’s motion to dismiss, filed before unsealing, challenges both the legal theory and the timing. If prosecutors seek an indictment, they would need grand jury approval and could then pursue arrest and arraignment. McFadden has not ruled on the dismissal request.
The case revisits a decade-old dispute over how the FBI talked to reporters about surveillance programs, but its public debut lands amid a broader pattern of criminal cases against Trump critics and former national-security officials. Defense lawyers warned in court filings that prosecutors might have planned an after-hours arrest; no surrender timetable has been set.
