A federal judge in Los Angeles refused Wednesday to block California from counting ballots cast by up to 20,000 voters the Trump administration alleges are likely noncitizens, saying the Justice Department’s last-minute request would “wreak havoc” on a midterm election six days away.
U.S. District Judge Maame Frimpong ruled against the government after a hearing in which state lawyers argued that segregating or rejecting those ballots would disenfranchise eligible voters and overwhelm county registrars already processing mail-in returns. The department said it would appeal.
What the government sought
The lawsuit is part of a broader push by the administration to challenge voter rolls in Democratic-leaning states ahead of Nov. 4. Justice Department filings contend that California’s motor-voter and registration systems allowed people without citizenship documentation to remain on active lists, and they asked the court to order counties to set aside ballots from the flagged group until eligibility could be verified.
California Secretary of State Shirley Weber’s office countered that the federal list mixed outdated naturalization data with active registrations and that many of the 20,000 individuals had already provided proof of citizenship or were U.S.-born. Weber said counties had begun contacting affected voters and that none should be removed from the count without individual hearings required under state law.
Judge’s reasoning
Frimpong, an appointee of President Joe Biden, wrote that the timing alone weighed against the government. With early voting underway and election-day preparations fixed, she said, forcing counties to reconfigure ballot-processing workflows risked missing statutory deadlines for certifying results in tight congressional races.
She also said the administration had not shown a likelihood of success on the merits at this stage, noting that federal law generally leaves day-to-day election administration to states unless Congress acts. Her order leaves California free to continue its standard verification process, which includes post-election audits of sampled precincts.
Broader midterm context
The California case landed as Trump directed prosecutors to prepare challenges to a potential Democratic win in Alaska’s Senate race and as the department issued more than 100 subpoenas seeking voter records in at least 13 states, according to Reuters. Election officials in multiple jurisdictions warned that the volume of litigation and investigative demands could undermine public confidence if races tighten.
Since Trump returned to office, the Justice Department has charged at least 147 people with illegal voting, Reuters reported, a figure that remains far below one case per million votes cast in 2024. Administration officials say the enforcement wave is meant to deter fraud, while voting-rights groups call it intimidation.
Next steps
The department’s appeal will go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which could act on an emergency motion before Tuesday. County officials in Los Angeles, the nation’s largest voting jurisdiction, said they would continue scanning and storing ballots under existing protocols and would comply with any higher-court order if one arrives before certification deadlines.
For now, the ruling keeps California on its pre-election footing: flagged registrations remain under review, but their ballots stay in the count unless a future court order says otherwise.
