Victoria’s Court of Appeal on Friday rejected Erin Patterson’s bid to overturn her murder convictions and removed the 33-year non-parole period on her life sentences, leaving the 52-year-old with no scheduled release date after poisoning relatives with death cap mushrooms in a beef Wellington lunch.
Justices Stephen McLeish, Lesley Taylor and Peter Kidd upheld prosecutors’ argument that the original sentence was too lenient for what they called “extraordinarily cold and calculated” killings. Patterson did not attend the brief hearing in person and showed no visible reaction on a video link as the court published its reasons.
The crimes and the trial
A jury last year found Patterson guilty of murdering her former in-laws Don and Gail Patterson and Gail’s sister Heather Wilkinson, and of attempting to murder Heather’s husband Ian Wilkinson, who survived after eating the 2023 meal at her Leongatha home in Gippsland. Death cap fungi baked into the Wellington were identified as the cause.
Patterson has maintained she did not know the mushrooms were toxic. The appeal court’s judgment said the offending was so shocking that fixing any non-parole period was inappropriate, and that the sentence would now expire only upon her death.
Legal avenues left
Legal researchers said Patterson has exhausted the standard conviction appeal path in Victoria and would need rare leave for a second appeal or a challenge in the High Court of Australia. Melbourne defence lawyer Lauren Cassimatis told ABC NewsRadio that removing non-parole altogether is uncommon and likely to be tested at the highest court if her team pursues it.
The ruling closes a chapter that drew global attention to rural Victoria and to how deadly foraged mushrooms can be when mixed into home cooking. Police and prosecutors had presented Patterson’s communications and conduct around the lunch as evidence of intent.
What happens next
Patterson returns to custody under the revised life terms while her lawyers decide whether to seek High Court special leave. Victims’ relatives have followed the appeal closely; the court’s published reasons run to more than a hundred pages detailing why each ground of appeal failed.
For the Victorian justice system, the decision sets a marker on sentencing for multiple homicides involving poison, a category judges said required the strongest available denunciation.
Media coverage of the appeal drew crowds to Melbourne’s legal precinct, where reporters parsed the bench’s language on “shocking criminality” as a signal to future sentencing courts. The Director of Public Prosecutions had argued that any fixed non-parole term understated the deliberate nature of serving a lethal meal to estranged family members.
Gippsland communities that hosted the original trial continue to grapple with the case’s notoriety, but Friday’s ruling is a final appellate word unless the High Court intervenes. Corrections Victoria will hold Patterson under the updated life order without a parole calendar.
