Parliament tabled a Town Councils (Amendment) Bill on Friday that would require every town council to publish lift modernisation escrow balances online each month, after MPs argued residents paying higher service-and-conservancy charges cannot see whether funds are ring-fenced for lift upgrades or absorbed into general operating accounts.

What the bill would change

The proposed section 34A would oblige councils to break out amounts held specifically for lift replacement and major modernisation, separate from routine lift maintenance contracts. Councils would post the figures on their websites within 14 days of each month-end, alongside the auditor-certified statement already filed with the Ministry of National Development. Failure to publish would become an offence carrying fines of up to S$10,000 per month of default.

Workers' Party MP He Ting Ru told the House that lift breakdowns remain among the top complaints at her Sengkang town council surgeries, yet residents who approved higher sinking-fund contributions during estate meetings received only aggregate balance sheets. People's Action Party MP Melvin Yong, who chairs the Government Parliamentary Committee for National Development, said transparency would not by itself shorten contractor queues but would stop councils from quietly reallocating earmarked sums when operating deficits widen.

Why lifts keep dominating town council politics

HDB estimates that more than 3,100 lifts across older estates will need replacement or full modernisation before 2030 as original equipment passes its design life. Town councils typically finance the work through a mix of sinking-fund draws, government lift enhancement subsidies and phased SC&C increases approved at resident meetings. When multiple blocks in a precinct share a single contractor slot, delays in one block can cascade, fuelling suspicion that money was moved elsewhere.

The Building and Construction Authority's lift registry shows average callback rates falling after modernisation, but upfront costs often exceed S$200,000 per lift shaft. Councils that front-load escrow collections argue they are protecting future cohorts of flat owners; critics say without granular disclosure, today's payers cannot verify that claim.

Committee stage and resident meetings

The bill is scheduled for a second reading in November. If passed, MND said transitional rules would give councils six months to migrate accounting systems before the first mandatory escrow disclosure due in mid-2027. Town councils would still set SC&C rates locally, but the ministry could withhold lift subsidy top-ups from councils that miss two consecutive reporting deadlines.

Resident committees in Ang Mo Kio and Jurong West told CNA they welcome machine-readable escrow tables because many elderly owners compare PDF statements by hand. Council managers counter that escrow balances fluctuate when contractors invoice milestones, warning that monthly snapshots could be misread as misspending during active projects.

What happens next

Opposition MPs plan amendments requiring councils to link each escrow line item to named lift contracts, not just aggregate balances. The government said it will respond at committee stage, noting that contract values are commercially sensitive until tenders close. For flat owners, the immediate stake is simpler: whether the next SC&C hike vote comes with a number they can audit from their phone, not only from a town hall slide deck.

Accounting systems town halls

Ang Mo Kio Town Council told residents at a Thursday town hall that its escrow ledger already exists internally but is merged into a broader sinking-fund worksheet auditors see once a year. Publishing monthly online would require separating lift modernisation codes in its SAP instance, a three-month IT project the bill's transitional window is meant to fund. Jurong-Clementi Town Council said it supports disclosure but asked MND for template tables so smaller councils do not each invent incompatible formats.

HDB's Lift Upgrading Programme subsidies still cover part of modernisation bills, and MPs want escrow reporting to show when government grants arrive, not only resident contributions. Without that line, critics say councils could draw subsidies while still collecting duplicate escrow top-ups. MND replied that grant disbursements are already logged in annual reports, but conceded the new clause may add a grant column at committee stage.