Lord Leveson, the investigatory powers commissioner, said Thursday that MI5’s false evidence to multiple courts while defending a violent neo-Nazi informant known as Agent X ranks among the most serious accountability failures he has handled, telling oversight staff that candour to judges is the foundation on which parliamentary control of intelligence rests.

What IPCO found

The Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office investigated how MI5 told the High Court and Investigatory Powers Tribunal that it had maintained its “neither confirm nor deny” policy about Agent X’s status as a covert human intelligence source. IPCO concluded that account was false: senior officers had disclosed the man’s agent role to the BBC in 2020 while trying to block a broadcast, according to the commissioner’s published remarks and earlier BBC reporting that triggered the probe.

A detailed IPCO report deposited with Parliament found one senior officer lied repeatedly and another misled colleagues and courts about what he was told. MI5 accepted the findings “without reservation” last month, the BBC reported, but the High Court has yet to decide whether to pursue contempt or other sanctions against the service or individual officers.

Why Leveson escalated the language now

In comments marking his annual report, Leveson said Prime Minister Keir Starmer had directed him to determine how false evidence reached the courts. “My investigation has now concluded and found that both IPCO and the courts were misled,” he said, adding that “oversight depends on candour” and that failures of candour “undermine the entire basis of oversight and accountability.”

The Agent X case stems from BBC reporting on a neo-Nazi informant who abused a partner identified in court as Beth. MI5 sought injunctions and NCND rulings that kept information from her, asserting the secrecy policy had never been broken. IPCO’s file shows case handlers knew NCND had been departed from in phone calls with a BBC journalist, yet witness statements to the courts continued to deny it.

Regulatory and court timeline

The Divisional Court and Investigatory Powers Tribunal both found in July 2025 that MI5 relied on false evidence when seeking an injunction against the BBC, when resisting Beth’s tribunal claim and when challenging the tribunal’s NCND decision. IPCO’s subsequent investigation, completed this year, traced responsibility across several senior officers and cited systemic failures to correct the record once internal files showed NCND had been breached.

Leveson’s office supervises MI5, MI6 and GCHQ under the Investigatory Powers Act. His statement does not itself impose penalties; that remains for the High Court and for internal MI5 discipline processes, which the service has not detailed publicly.

What happens next

Lawyers for Beth and for media interveners are watching the High Court’s next move on contempt and costs. Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee can also summon witnesses if it chooses to reopen scrutiny. For now, Leveson’s message is procedural: without truthful filings, the tribunals that authorize surveillance and protect sources cannot function, and the Agent X case will be cited in every future dispute over whether spy agencies told judges the full story.