South Korea's media regulator on Wednesday imposed 63.71 billion won in combined fines on Google and Apple after a three-year investigation found their app store payment rules effectively forced developers to use first-party billing.

The Korea Media and Communications Commission approved corrective orders alongside the fines but decided not to refer either company for criminal prosecution. The penalties implement a 2021 amendment to the Telecommunications Business Act that barred store operators from mandating specific payment methods or delaying reviews without cause.

Why regulators called it serious

Investigators said both platforms technically allowed third-party billing yet attached fees and UX restrictions that made alternatives uneconomic. Developers using outside payment systems still faced commissions around 26 percent plus their own processing costs, while Google limited how prices could be displayed across methods and Apple required separate app submissions for third-party checkout.

Apple also paid an additional penalty related to commission calculations on Korean developers versus overseas sellers from 2015 to 2023, a discrepancy regulators estimated generated 149.6 billion won in extra fees. KMCC staff classified the conduct as a "very serious violation" during a televised briefing at the government complex in Gwacheon.

Orders beyond the fine print

Commissioners ordered the companies to permit external payment links inside apps, improve third-party fee disclosures and explain review delays with timelines when developers ask. Each firm must submit compliance plans within one month and implement procedural fixes within three months, though officials declined to set hard launch dates for consumer-visible changes.

Regulators noted they cannot cap commission rates on new outlink payments, leaving open whether Google and Apple will attach smaller fees that still steer traffic to in-app billing. Spokespeople for the U.S. companies had not published detailed responses by late afternoon, but prior statements have defended security benefits of centralized checkout.

Seoul versus other capitals

Wednesday's sanctions arrive as Brussels and Tokyo deploy different penalty formulas tied to global revenue. KMCC officials acknowledged their statutory cap near 3 percent of relevant sales limits deterrence and said rule revisions raising ceilings are underway. For Korean game studios and fintech startups, the decision matters less as a one-time charge to multinationals and more as a test of whether local courts will enforce alternative payment buttons users can actually see.

Developers who complained about opaque review queues may get the first tangible benefit if timelines arrive before holiday releases. Until then, the fines function as a down payment on a market structure lawmakers promised when they passed the "Google law" half a decade ago.