The government is inviting tens of thousands of welfare recipients to seek compensation while simultaneously switching back on the same automated compliance machinery that unlawfully cancelled payments—an incoherent pair of messages that treats redress as a substitute for repair.

Compensation is not a reset button

We supported the Commonwealth Ombudsman’s finding that 964 cancellations breached the law. We welcome the $870,000 already paid to more than 600 people. But restarting suspensions before Parliament sees evidence that IT fixes eliminated early-cutoff bugs asks households to trust a system that stranded jobseekers without income for years.

What proof would look like

Department officials cite training, communications and system testing. That is necessary, not sufficient. Publish the regression tests. Show independent auditors signed off on timing rules introduced after the December 2020 IT change that triggered premature cancellations.

Until then, automatic suspensions should remain paused for cohorts with zero mutual obligations—the very group Adelaide man Daniel belonged to when his payments stopped despite having no activities to report.

A political choice

Labor fears being branded weak on compliance enforcement. The stronger political risk is another ombudsman report mid-election year. Every unlawful cancellation becomes a story about automation without accountability.

We do not argue against mutual obligation itself. We argue against flipping the enforcement switch back on while 50,652 invitation letters for compensation are still landing in mailboxes. Fix the engine, prove it, then resume penalties—not the reverse.

Ministers should bring legislation if they want new powers. Silent reliance on opaque algorithms already failed once. Australians deserve a compliance regime they can see and challenge before it again drains their accounts.

Parliament’s role

Senate estimates should require the department to table error rates weekly during the restart period. Without transparency, compensation letters become a one-off apology while the underlying automation keeps churning suspensions that families must appeal at their own expense.

Household cash flow

Even short suspensions trigger late fees on rent and utilities when direct debits bounce. We should measure success by how many households never enter the appeals queue—not by how quickly penalties resume.