InfoHandle Editorial: The Securities and Exchange Board of India was right to pause expansion of same-day T+0 settlement until brokers, not just exchanges, ask for it with real volume behind them.

The pilot that began in March 2024 never escaped novelty status. Twenty-five stocks qualified, yet dual settlement tracks threatened to split liquidity between T+1 pools that retail investors understand and an optional same-day lane that market makers could ignore on volatile days.

What the pilot showed

Qualified stock brokers completed most systems work, but reported wafer-thin client uptake. Same-day settlement shines when intraday traders need immediate cash for the next session; India’s cash market participation is still dominated by delivery investors and SIP flows that do not benefit from shaving twelve hours off fund availability.

Exchanges liked the marketing halo of “instant” trades, yet depth data showed no sustained tightening of spreads on pilot names. Liquidity providers said maintaining two collateral pipelines raised operational risk without compensating revenue.

Protect T+1 first

India moved from T+2 to T+1 faster than many developed markets, a shift that required depositories, banks and brokers to retool simultaneously. That project is still settling. Forcing a parallel T+0 stack would recreate the dual-track frictions T+1 was meant to eliminate, especially for corporate actions and short deliveries.

Foreign portfolio investors also flagged concerns that same-day cycles complicate currency hedging when trades fail and roll to the next window. Keeping T+1 as the default preserves predictability for the overseas funds that returned as net buyers in October.

When T+0 might return

SEBI should reopen expansion only if a critical mass of brokers opt in voluntarily and publish audited uptake statistics quarterly. Mandating T+0 for large caps would be a mistake until retail demand proves itself beyond trading desk experiments.

Innovation in Indian markets should focus next on settlement fails, not speed for its own sake. Faster is not better if it drains depth from the main pool millions of investors already use.

Market participants said exchanges should publish monthly T+0 uptake tables alongside regular turnover statistics so policy debates rely on audited figures rather than anecdote.

Until then, maintaining a single default settlement cycle keeps back-office costs predictable for the regional banks that custody most retail demat accounts.